| Competition | 1 Place | 2 Place | 3 Place | 4 Place |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Premier League 2024 |
||||
|
Premier League 2023 |
||||
|
Premier League 2019 |
 BDF |
Weymouth Wales |
UWI Blackbirds |
Empire Club |
|
Premier League 2018 |
Weymouth Wales |
BDF |
UWI Blackbirds |
Paradise |
|
Premier League 2017 |
Weymouth Wales |
Notre Dame |
BDF |
Brittons Hill |
|
Premier League 2016 |
BDF |
Notre Dame |
Paradise |
Empire Club |
|
Premier League 2015 |
BDF |
UWI Blackbirds |
Rendezvous |
Paradise |
|
Premier League 2014 |
Pinelands United |
Pride of Gall Hill |
Weymouth Wales |
|
|
Premier League 2013 |
Notre Dame |
Brittons Hill |
Pride of Gall Hill |
|
|
Premier League 2012 |
Weymouth Wales |
Brittons Hill |
BDF |
Pride of Gall Hill |
|
Premier League 2011 |
Notre Dame |
Weymouth Wales |
Paradise |
Youth Milan |
|
Premier League 2010 |
Notre Dame |
Pride of Gall Hill |
||
|
Premier League 2009 |
Brittons Hill |
BDF |
Pride of Gall Hill |
Silver Sands |
|
Premier League 2008 |
Notre Dame |
Brittons Hill |
BDF |
Paradise |
|
Premier League 2007 |
BDF |
Pride of Gall Hill |
Brittons Hill |
Silver Sands |
|
Premier League 2006 |
Youth Milan |
Notre Dame |
Silver Sands |
BDF |
Titles and finals
| 1 | Notre Dame |
4 |
| 2 | BDF |
4 |
| 3 | Weymouth Wales |
3 |
| 4 | 2 | |
| 5 | Pinelands United |
1 |
| 6 | Youth Milan |
1 |
| 7 | Brittons Hill |
1 |
